In the vibrant borough of Manhattan, where the skyline stretches toward endless possibilities, many New Yorkers find themselves asking an important question: "Does a felony stay on your record forever?" This question echoes through the halls of justice from Foley Square to the bustling streets surrounding Grand Central Terminal, affecting countless individuals seeking a fresh start.

At Varghese & Associates, P.C., we understand the weight of this question for our clients across the five boroughs. While you might enjoy the freedom of walking through Central Park or catching the Staten Island Ferry, having a felony stay on your record can create invisible barriers that limit your opportunities long after you've served your sentence.

The Criminal Records Landscape in New York State

When you stand before a judge in the majestic courtrooms of the New York County Courthouse at 60 Centre Street, a felony conviction becomes more than just a legal decision—it becomes part of your criminal history. Does a felony stay on your record permanently in New York? Understanding the answer requires knowledge of how criminal records work in the Empire State.

Criminal records in New York are maintained by multiple agencies, including the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) and the New York City Police Department. These records are accessible to employers, landlords, and other entities that conduct background checks, similar to how the MetroCard system tracks your movements throughout the city's extensive subway network.

The General Rule: Does a Felony Stay on Your Record Indefinitely?

As you gaze across the East River toward Brooklyn Bridge Park, you might wonder if your criminal record will follow you as persistently as Manhattan's skyline on the horizon. The straightforward answer to "Does a felony stay on your record?" is that, by default, a felony conviction does stay on your record indefinitely in New York State and throughout most of the United States.

Unlike misdemeanors, which might be comparable to a brief shower in Bryant Park—unpleasant but temporary—felony crime convictions tend to remain on your record permanently unless specific legal actions are taken. This permanence can affect:

• Employment opportunities at prestigious firms along Madison Avenue
• Housing applications for apartments from Battery Park City to Washington Heights
• Professional licensing requirements for careers throughout the five boroughs
• Immigration status for those dreaming of making New York City their permanent home
• Voting rights and civic participation in local elections

Just as the iconic Statue of Liberty stands as a permanent fixture in New York Harbor, typically, a felony conviction felony stay on your record as a permanent fixture unless you take specific legal measures to address it.

Exceptions: When Does a Felony Stay on Your Record for a Limited Time?

While walking the historic streets of Greenwich Village, and you might find comfort knowing that there are exceptions to the rule that a felony stay on your record forever. Certain circumstances can limit how long a felony conviction affects your life:

1. Youthful Offender Adjudications

For younger New Yorkers, offenses committed between the ages of 16 and 19 may qualify for Youthful Offender (YO) status. Like the seasonal ice skating rink at Rockefeller Center, these records aren't permanent fixtures—they're sealed automatically and not considered criminal convictions under New York law.

2. Record Sealing Under CPL 160.59

In 2017, as significant as the opening of the Second Avenue Subway, New York passed legislation allowing for the sealing of certain criminal convictions, including some felonies. Under Criminal Procedure Law § 160.59, eligible individuals can petition to have up to two criminal convictions (only one of which may be a felony) sealed after a 10-year waiting period.

So, does a felony stay on your record if you qualify for sealing? While the conviction technically remains in the system—similar to how the old City Hall subway station still exists though it's hidden from public view—sealed records are not visible to most employers or housing providers.

3. Certificate of Relief from Disabilities

Like finding an unexpected green space in the concrete jungle, a Certificate of Relief from Disabilities offers some respite from the effects of a criminal record. Though it doesn't remove the felony from your record, it can restore certain rights and reduce some collateral consequences of conviction.

4. Certificate of Good Conduct

For those with multiple felony convictions, much like navigating the complex intersections of Times Square, the path to relief may be through a Certificate of Good Conduct. This certificate can be obtained after a waiting period of 1-5 years, depending on the severity of the offenses.

Does a Felony Stay on Your Record for FBI Background Checks?

As you walk past the imposing federal buildings in Lower Manhattan, you might wonder about federal background checks. Does a felony stay on your record for FBI purposes even if it's sealed at the state level?

Federal databases, including the FBI's National Crime Information Center (NCIC), generally maintain records of felony convictions regardless of state-level relief. This means that certain positions requiring federal criminal background checks—such as jobs at the United Nations headquarters on the East River or federal positions at 26 Federal Plaza—may still reveal sealed felony convictions.

Industry-Specific Considerations: How Long Does a Felony Stay on Your Record?

For professionals wondering, "Does a felony stay on your record forever?" the impact of a felony conviction varies across different sectors, much like how the character of New York changes as you move from neighborhood to neighborhood:

Financial Industry

For those aspiring to work in the financial district, where Wall Street's towering institutions shape global markets, securities regulations impose strict background check requirements. FINRA regulations mean that a felony conviction, particularly one involving fraud or financial misconduct, can create significant barriers to employment in this sector.

Healthcare

In a city with prestigious medical centers like NewYork-Presbyterian and NYU Langone Health, healthcare professionals face thorough background screening. Felony convictions, especially those involving controlled substances or patient harm, may permanently disqualify individuals from certain healthcare roles.

Education

For those hoping to work in New York City's diverse school system, spanning from the elite private schools of the Upper East Side to public schools in Corona, Queens, background checks are particularly thorough. Does a felony stay on your record for teaching positions? Unfortunately, certain felonies may permanently disqualify individuals from working in educational settings.

Transportation

In a city where millions rely on taxis, ride-sharing services, and the MTA, transportation jobs often require clean records. The Taxi and Limousine Commission conducts background checks that can reveal felony convictions, potentially limiting job opportunities in this sector.

The Digital Footprint: Does a Felony Stay on Your Record Online?

As permanent as the Empire State Building on the Manhattan skyline, digital records have created new challenges for those with felony convictions. Private background check companies, much like the countless tourists in Times Square, constantly capture and share information.

Even when a felony conviction is sealed officially, digital traces of the felony stay on your record in:

• Private database companies based in Manhattan's tech hubs
• News articles from publications like the New York Post or Times
• Court record aggregator websites with offices throughout Midtown
• Public records accessed before sealing took effect

These digital footprints can create situations where a felony technically no longer appears on your official record but remains visible through unofficial channels.

Addressing the Problem: Does a Felony Stay on Your Record?

For New Yorkers wondering, "Does a felony stay on your record forever?" the path forward involves several practical steps:

1. Obtain Your Criminal Record

Just as you might check the MTA app before planning your subway journey, start by obtaining a copy of your criminal record to understand exactly what appears. You can request this information from the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services.

2. Determine Eligibility for Sealing or Certificates

Like finding the perfect route from Brooklyn to the Bronx, navigating record relief requires understanding your options. Not all felonies qualify for sealing under CPL 160.59. Sex offenses, violent felonies, and certain serious offenses are generally excluded.

3. Consult with a Criminal Record Attorney

The landscape of criminal record relief is as complex as navigating SoHo's narrow streets during a festival. At Varghese & Associates, P.C., we help clients understand their specific situations and identify the most appropriate remedies.

4. Prepare a Comprehensive Application

Whether seeking record sealing or certificates, the application process requires thorough documentation, similar to assembling the perfect application for a coveted Manhattan co-op. This includes evidence of rehabilitation, employment history, and community contributions.

5. Address Digital Footprints

In the digital age, managing your online presence is as important as maintaining your reputation in your neighborhood. Legal strategies may include working with reputation management services to address online information about past convictions.

Navigating the Expungement Process

Are you frustrated by having an old felony stay on your record? At Varghese & Associates, P.C., we guide clients through New York's record-clearing options, including the limited expungement opportunities and the more widely available sealing mechanisms. Our strategic approach helps maximize your chances of success in removing barriers created by past criminal records.

• Initial eligibility assessment: We thoroughly review your complete criminal history to determine which records qualify for expungement or sealing under current New York law.
• Record acquisition: Our team obtains certified copies of all relevant court documents, rap sheets, and supporting records necessary for your expungement or sealing application.
• Waiting period verification: We confirm you've satisfied the mandatory time requirements since conviction or completion of sentence before initiating the expungement process.
• Marijuana conviction expungement: Our attorneys verify that automatic marijuana expungement has been properly processed or file manual applications for eligible cannabis-related convictions under New York's legalization legislation.
• Strategic case selection: For clients with multiple convictions, we identify which cases to prioritize for relief based on eligibility criteria and potential impact on your specific goals.
• Supporting documentation compilation: We gather evidence of rehabilitation, employment history, educational achievements, and community contributions to strengthen your application.
• Petition preparation: Our lawyers draft comprehensive petitions that present compelling legal and personal narratives demonstrating why your record should be cleared.
• Prosecutor notification: We manage the required notification to the District Attorney's office and strategically address any objections they may raise to your expungement request.
• Court representation: Our attorneys appear on your behalf at all required hearings, presenting persuasive arguments tailored to the specific judge assigned to your case.
• Agency notification coordination: Following successful expungement or sealing, we ensure all relevant agencies properly update their records to reflect the court's order.
• Private database management: We take additional steps to address outdated information in commercial background check databases after your official records are cleared.
• Employment rights counseling: Our team provides guidance on how to legally answer questions about expunged or sealed convictions on job applications and during interviews.
• Expungement alternatives: When traditional expungement isn't available, we pursue Certificates of Relief from Disabilities, Certificates of Good Conduct, or executive pardons as alternative remedies.
• Interstate record clearance: For clients with multi-state records, we coordinate with affiliate attorneys to address criminal history issues across different jurisdictions.
• Post-expungement verification: Our services include follow-up record checks to confirm your expunged or sealed information has been properly removed from accessible databases.

Does a Felony Stay on Your Record: How a Criminal Record Lawyer Can Help

Tired of having an old felony stay on your record? At Varghese & Associates, P.C., our criminal record lawyers provide essential guidance through the complex legal process of addressing your criminal history in New York. Our team offers strategic solutions tailored to your specific circumstances.

• Record evaluation and analysis: We thoroughly examine your complete criminal history to identify all convictions, dismissals, and pending matters that may appear on background checks.
• Sealing eligibility assessment: Our attorneys determine whether your felony or misdemeanor convictions qualify for sealing under New York's CPL 160.59 and other relevant statutes.
• Expungement petition possibilities: We explore all available options for completely removing certain offenses from your record, particularly for cases involving marijuana convictions under recent legislative changes.
• Certificate of Relief from Disabilities: Our team guides you through the application process to restore specific rights lost due to your criminal record, enhancing employment opportunities.
• Certificate of Good Conduct: We help eligible clients with multiple convictions navigate this important relief option that can remove barriers to licensing and employment.
• Employment rights advocacy: Our criminal defense lawyers ensure employers follow proper procedures regarding your criminal record under New York City's Fair Chance Act and state regulations.
• Housing application assistance: We address illegal discrimination based on criminal history in housing situations throughout the five boroughs.
• Professional license representation: Our criminal defense attorneys advocate for clients seeking occupational licenses despite criminal records, presenting compelling evidence of rehabilitation.
• Immigration consequences management: We analyze how criminal records affect immigration status and develop strategies to minimize negative impacts on residency or citizenship applications.
• Background check disputes: Our team identifies and corrects errors or outdated information appearing on commercial background checks to prevent unjust denial of opportunities.
• Pardon application preparation: For appropriate cases, we develop comprehensive pardon applications highlighting rehabilitation, community contributions, and personal growth.
• Record-related litigation: When necessary, we pursue legal action against entities that improperly use or disclose sealed criminal record information.
• Strategic disclosure guidance: We provide practical advice on when, how, and what aspects of your criminal history to disclose in various professional and personal contexts.
• Comprehensive reentry planning: Our expungement lawyers develop holistic strategies addressing multiple collateral consequences affecting housing, employment, education, and civic participation.
• Ongoing compliance monitoring: We ensure all agencies properly implement sealing orders and other relief granted by the courts, taking swift action when violations occur.

Criminal Record Cases We Take

For New Yorkers wondering, "Does a felony stay on your record forever?" we represent clients throughout the city who seek to overcome the barriers created by having a felony stay on their criminal records. Our attorneys handle a comprehensive range of record-related matters to help you move forward with your life.

• Record sealing applications: We prepare and file petitions under CPL 160.59 to seal eligible felony and misdemeanor convictions after the required waiting period has passed.
• Marijuana conviction expungement: Our firm handles automatic expungement verification and manual applications for marijuana-related convictions eligible for relief under New York's marijuana legalization law.
• Certificate of Relief from Disabilities: We guide clients through the application process for this important certificate that removes automatic barriers to employment and licensing.
• Certificate of Good Conduct: Our attorneys assist individuals with multiple convictions in obtaining this certificate after the mandatory waiting period to restore rights and improve opportunities.
• Youthful offender adjudications: We help clients ensure their YO cases are properly sealed and address any instances where these confidential records have been improperly disclosed.
• Non-conviction sealing: Our team secures the sealing of arrests that ended in dismissals, acquittals, or declined prosecutions to prevent these incidents from appearing on background checks.
• Conditional sealing matters: We represent clients eligible for conditional sealing after successful completion of judicial diversion or drug treatment programs.
• Violent felony record relief: Our attorneys explore specialized options for clients with violent felony convictions, including partial sealing, certificates, and executive clemency applications.
• Executive pardons: We prepare comprehensive pardon applications for clients with extraordinary circumstances or evidence of complete rehabilitation.
• Occupational licensing cases: Our firm represents professionals whose license applications are complicated by criminal records, including in healthcare, education, financial services, and other regulated industries.
• Employment discrimination matters: We advocate for clients who have faced illegal discrimination based on criminal history contrary to New York City's Fair Chance Act and state protections.
• Housing denial appeals: Our attorneys challenge improper denials of housing based on criminal records, ensuring housing authorities and landlords comply with relevant laws.
• Background check disputes: We help clients identify and correct inaccurate or outdated information appearing in commercial background checks through formal dispute processes.
• Record-based immigration relief: Our team addresses the complex intersection between criminal records and immigration status, including applications for waivers and special relief.
• FBI record challenges: We assist clients in correcting errors in federal databases that may affect employment, licensing, or firearm rights despite state-level relief.

Changing Perspectives: Does a Felony Stay on Your Record?

Just as New York City constantly evolves—from the development of Hudson Yards to the ongoing changes in Queens' Long Island City—laws regarding criminal records continue to develop. Criminal justice reform advocates throughout the city are working to expand record relief opportunities.

Recent developments suggest a growing recognition that permanent records create permanent barriers to reintegration. Proposed legislation, like discussions happening in Albany's legislative chambers, may eventually expand sealing eligibility or even create pathways to expungement—the complete erasure of certain convictions.

Take the First Step Toward a Clean Slate Today

Are you embarrassed by having an old felony stay on your record? Explore your options with legal representation. Our experienced attorneys are prepared to evaluate your case and develop a personalized strategy to address your record concerns. Schedule a confidential consultation with Varghese & Associates, P.C., and begin your journey toward a future not defined by your past.

Felony Criminal Record FAQs

How soon after conviction can I apply to have my record sealed in New York? New York law requires a 10-year waiting period from the date of conviction or release from incarceration, whichever is later, before you can apply for sealing under CPL 160.59. This waiting period allows you to demonstrate rehabilitation and establish a positive track record.

Will sealing my record completely remove it from all databases? No, sealing does not completely erase your record. Sealed records remain accessible to law enforcement agencies, certain licensing boards, and some government entities. However, sealed records will not appear on most standard background checks conducted by employers or landlords.

Can a DWI conviction be sealed in New York? Most DWI convictions cannot be sealed under current New York law. DWI offenses are specifically excluded from eligibility under CPL 160.59, regardless of how much time has passed since the conviction.

How is sealing different from expungement? Sealing limits who can access your criminal record, while expungement completely erases it from official records. New York generally offers sealing rather than expungement, with the exception of certain marijuana convictions which qualify for true expungement under recent legislation.

Do I need to attend a court hearing for my record sealing application? It depends on your specific case. Some sealing applications are decided on paper submissions alone, while others require a court appearance. If the District Attorney's office objects to your sealing request, a hearing will typically be scheduled.

If my sealing application is denied, can I apply again later? Yes, you can reapply if your initial sealing application is denied. However, we recommend addressing the specific reasons for denial before submitting a new application. There is no statutory waiting period between applications, but courts may view multiple rapid reapplications unfavorably.

Will sealing my New York record affect how my conviction appears in other states? Sealing your record in New York does not automatically extend to other states. If your conviction information has already been shared with other jurisdictions or private background check companies, those records may remain visible unless you take separate action in each relevant location.

Can juvenile records affect me as an adult in New York? Most juvenile delinquency records in New York are automatically sealed when you turn 16 (for older cases) or upon case completion (for newer cases). However, some serious juvenile offenses may remain accessible in certain circumstances unless specific sealing relief is obtained.

How do fingerprint-based background checks differ from name-based checks? Fingerprint-based background checks access official FBI and state repositories and are typically more thorough and accurate. Name-based checks, conducted by private companies, may contain outdated or incorrect information and often miss records if you've used different name variations.

Do I need to disclose sealed convictions on job applications? For most private employment in New York, you can legally answer "no" when asked about sealed convictions. However, certain positions in law enforcement, education, and financial services may require disclosure of all convictions regardless of sealing status.

Can the military see my sealed criminal record? Yes, military recruiters have access to sealed criminal records through federal databases. If you're considering military service, full disclosure of your criminal history is required regardless of whether your records have been sealed at the state level.

How do criminal records affect professional licensing in New York? New York licensing boards can consider criminal convictions when evaluating applications, but must assess factors like time elapsed, rehabilitation evidence, and relevance to the specific profession. Many boards can access sealed records, making professional representation particularly valuable.

What happens if a background check company reports sealed information? If a background check company reports sealed conviction information, you may have grounds for legal action under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, New York State law, and potentially New York City's Fair Chance Act. Our law firm can help you address these violations.

Can immigration authorities see sealed criminal records? Yes, federal immigration authorities have access to sealed criminal records. Non-citizens should seek both criminal record counsel and immigration advice when addressing record issues, as strategies that work well for citizens may have adverse immigration consequences.

How long does the record sealing process take in New York? The sealing process typically takes between 4-8 months from initial application to final decision. This timeline can vary significantly based on the court's caseload, whether the District Attorney files an objection, and whether a hearing is required.

Charged with a Federal Crime? We’re Ready to Fight Back

The government has prosecutors. You deserve an aggressive, experienced defense.

Call (212) 430-6469 to speak with a New York City federal criminal defense lawyer today, or contact us online for a confidential consultation.

📞 Call (212) 430-6469 Contact Us